Pomodori's Pizzeria

(513) 861-0080

121 W Mcmillan St
Cincinnati, OH 45219 39.1276 -84.5168

Neighborhood: CUF

Reviews & Ratings for Pomodori's Pizzeria

4 Star Rating: Recommended

14 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a review

Showing 1-10 of 14 reviews

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

1 Star Rating: Poor

by JTDavis

June 16, 2009

It made me sad to see a local Clifton restaurant go so far downhill so quickly. In previous years I had always had good service and at least adequate food at Pomodori’s. However, the last time I ordered it was in the evening after work. I got fettuccini alfredo that appeared to have been cooked either very early in the morning or the day before. It was so disgusting that I could not manage to eat any of it, and merely threw it in the trash. Their prices are far too high (it cost 14.00) to be serving food that is such a low quality. To anyone craving Italian I recommend shopping around, there are far better restaurants.

  • Pros: None. Too bad I can't score lower than a 1 star.
  • Cons: Terrible food.

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

1 Star Rating: Poor

by ConcernedCliftonite

October 29, 2008

The food took FOREVER! Our drinks were empty the entire night, there were only two other people in the dining room and it just took forever to get anything. Then, when the food came, the pizza was somehow burnt, but still cold?! and it seemed like the ravioli and the salads were wading in a pool of ice water. Just overall, not good!!

  • Pros: None
  • Cons: Gross food and bad service

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

3 Star Rating: Average

by sdflick

October 12, 2008

I was totally let down by this pizza. I thought just by the name of the restaurant that the pizza might have some pizazz or something but it was plain, and no one in our family gathering liked it.

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

3 Star Rating: Average

by andrewb1

January 08, 2008

I love the quality of food offered, however, the consistency is really off. It seems to be very difficult to get an order correct. Whether is is sauce on the side- or leave off the tomato- it isn't happening. I have returned for the food, but always have to remind the waitress to refill a drink. They need to write the orders down. I always have to send back the order because it is incorrect. The atmosphere is too relaxed for the price! What a disappointment.

  • Pros: food quality
  • Cons: poor service and consistency

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

4 Star Rating: Recommended

by Contributor

August 10, 2006

In Short
The location next to the University of Cincinnati campus draws a high concentration of pizza-lovin' students. The usual professionals can't resist the wood-fired specialties and salads, either. The oven is on display, so you can watch them make your dinner. The wood-fired pizzas are smaller pies with a smoky flavor in the crisp crust. In addition to the hand-tossed crust, the menu offers creations like the prosciutto pizza with red onions and pressed garlic, seafood broccoli, and clams with green onion and roasted red pepper.

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by mis

May 19, 2005

I enjoyed the atmosphere and friendliness of the employees. I reccomend the pasta and pizza.

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by tatmom

March 07, 2003

The best part of Clifton ...hands down! Makes the trip to this community worth the drive.

  • Pros: the oven, style baby, atmosphere
  • Cons: limited parking, location, price

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

4 Star Rating: Recommended

by pelapo

November 24, 2002

great food. unique and excellent mouth eatering great carbonera good lemonade

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by Oldiesmann

November 08, 2002

My family has kind of a tradition of Friday night being pizza night, so this time I recommended Pomodori's because I had never had their pizza, yet I'd heard that it was very good. It was excellent. Thick crust, tasty cheese and pepperoni made for one of the best pizzas I'd had in a long time.

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by ikuhlinger

November 06, 2002

My older brother who lives in Mt. Adams took me to Clifton "Corryville" to have lunch at a place I had never been before for food. The pizza from Pomodori's wood fired stove was "out of this world" the best that I had ever tried and I am a die hard Buddy LaRosa pizza fan. Now evertime I come home to Cincinnati I will make it a point to visit Pomodori's for a great pizza to enjoy.

  • Pros: stand out taste, great service, full ambience

Write comment on this review

Advertisement

Things To Do Nearby Pomodori's Pizzeria

brought to you by Visa

Pomodori's Pizzeria

121 W Mcmillan St
Cincinnati, OH 45219

Lists In Cincinnati

Recent Reviews In Cincinnati

4 Star Rating: Recommended

The Precinct

311 Delta Ave, Cincinnati, OH

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Arthur's

3516 Edwards Rd, Cincinnati, OH

1 Star Rating: Poor

Ban Thai

792 Eastgate South Dr Ste 300, Cincinnati, OH

Advertisement